中国城镇化的刘易斯转折——历史定位、实现形式和普遍意义The Lewis Transition of China's Urbanization:Historical Positioning, Realization Form and Universal Significance
吴垠,王明铠
摘要(Abstract):
新中国成立一百年时将实现中华民族伟大复兴的梦想,城镇化无疑是实现这一中国梦的重要篇章。选择什么样的城镇化道路,将最终决定中国城镇化发展的结果。这条城镇化道路应当而且必然是中国特色的新型城镇化道路。中国特色新型城镇化道路是以中国国情为背景,经过较长时间探索实践形成的一条既考虑中国自然社会历史条件,又借鉴国外城镇化成功经验的现实路径。它既不是完全自然历史形成的,也不是模仿国外某类城镇化道路而形成的固有模式。中国当前的城镇化道路正经历刘易斯转折期的考验,这对发展中国家跨越城镇化的刘易斯转折期的实践而言,既是一个巨大的社会实验观察室,也是一本富含城镇化建设多样性和复杂性的教科书。本文提出中国克服城镇化的刘易斯转折从1.0到5.0版本的城镇化实现形式,并指出中国求解城镇化刘易斯转折期矛盾的方案完全可为其他国家提供借鉴。
关键词(KeyWords): 中国城镇化;刘易斯转折;城镇化道路;普遍意义
基金项目(Foundation): 2022年度四川省留学人员科技活动项目择优资助重点项目“数字货币创新设计支持进阶版四川美好生活消费与防范化解重大金融风险研究”;; 研究阐释党的十九届六中全会精神国家社会科学基金重大项目“新发展阶段生产发展、生活富裕、生态良好的中国特色文明发展道路研究”(22ZDA108);; 国家社会科学基金“新发展阶段资本规范健康发展的经济法保障研究”(22CFX037);; 西南财经大学金融科技国际联合实验室重点项目“中国城市数字金融指数、数字金融资源配置、数字人民币应用与防风险研究——从整体到成渝地区双城经济圈”(FIC2022C0012);; 四川省金融学会2021年度重点课题的资助
作者(Author): 吴垠,王明铠
参考文献(References):
- 布洛克F.2010.后工业社会的可能性---经济学话语批判[M].王翼龙,译.北京:商务印书馆:13-14.(原书:BLOOK F.[1990].Postindustrial possibilities:Acritique of economic discourse[M].Berkeley:The University of California Press.)
- 蔡昉.2010.人口转变、人口红利与刘易斯转折点[J].经济研究,45(4):4-13.CAI F.2010.Demographic transition,demographic dividend,and Lewis turning point in China[J].Economic Research Journal,45(4):4-13.(in Chinese)
- 蔡昉.2013.中国收入分配:完成与未完成的任务[J].中国经济问题,(5):3-9.CAI F.2013.The income distribution in China:Finished and unfinished tasks[J].China Economic Studies,(5):3-9.(in Chinese)
- 蔡昉.2015.二元经济作为一个发展阶段的形成过程[J].经济研究,50(7):4-15.CAI F.2015.The formation process of dual economy as a stage of development[J].Economic Research Journal,50(7):4-15.(in Chinese)
- 段巍,王明,吴福象.2020.中国式城镇化的福利效应评价(2000-2017)---基于量化空间模型的结构估计[J].经济研究,55(5):166-182.DUAN W,WANG M,WU F X.2020.Welfare accounting of Chinese urbanization from 2000 to 2017:A structural estimation using the quantitative spatial model[J].Economic Research Journal,55(5):166-182.(in Chinese)
- 国家统计局.2020-02-28.2019年中国城镇化率突破60%户籍城镇化率44.38%[N].经济日报.
- 哈维D.2014.叛逆的城市:从城市权利到城市革命[M].叶齐茂,倪晓晖,译.北京:商务印书馆.(原书:HARVEY D.[2012].Rebel cities:From the right to the city to the urban revolution[M].London:Verso.)
- 胡鞍钢,任皓,鲁钰锋,等.2016.中国跨越中等收入陷阱:基于五大发展理念视角[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),(5):62-73.HU A G,REN H,LU Y F,et al.2016.China striding across middle income trap:From the perspective of five developmental concepts[J].Journal of Tsinghua University(Philosophy and Social Sciences),(5):62-73.(in Chinese)
- 姜卫平.2010.中国人口发展趋势[J].人口与计划生育,(8):9-10.JIANG W P.2010.China's population trends[J].Population and Family Planning,(8):9-10.(in Chinese)
- 罗知,万广华,张勋,等.2018.兼顾效率与公平的城镇化:理论模型与中国实证[J].经济研究,53(7):89-105.LUO Z,WAN G H,ZHANG X,et al.2018.Urbanization with considerations:Theory and evidence from China[J].Economic Research Journal,53(7):89-105.(in Chinese)
- 刘英骥,邓良.2010.金融危机后中国经济发展路径研究---基于制造业产值增长路径的视角[J].首都经济贸易大学学报,12(5):11-16.LIU Y J,DENG L.2010.China's economic development path after financial crisis:Based on the perspective of manufacturing industry output growth path[J].Journal of Capital University of Economics and Business,12(5):11-16.(in Chinese)
- 孟捷,龚剑.2014.金融资本与“阶级-垄断地租”---哈维对资本主义都市化的制度分析[J].中国社会科学,(8):91-108.MENG J,GONG J.2014.Finance capital and“Class-monopoly rent”:Harvey's institutional analysis of capitalist urbanization[J].Social Sciences in China,(8):91-108.(in Chinese)
- 马克思.1975.资本论(第一卷)[M].中共中央马克思恩格斯列宁斯大林著作编译局,译,北京:人民出版社.
- 马歇尔.1964.经济学原理(上)[M].朱志泰,陈良璧,译.北京:商务印书馆.(原书:MARSHALL A.[1890].Principles of economics[M].London:Mac Millan.)
- 配第W.1978.赋税论[M].陈冬野,译.北京:商务印书馆.(原书:PETTY W.[1662].A treatise of taxes and contribution[M].London:Obadiah Blagrave.)
- 诺顿B.2010.中国经济:转型与增长[M].安佳,译.上海:上海人民出版社:65.(原书:NAUGHTON B.[2007].The Chinese economy:Transitions and growth[M].Cambridge:The MIT Press.)
- 邵帅,李欣,曹建华.2019.中国的城市化推进与雾霾治理[J].经济研究,54(2):148-165.SHAO S,LI X.CAO J H.2019.Urbanization promotion and haze pollution governance in China[J].Economic Research Journal,54(2):148-165.(in Chinese)
- 斯密A.2001.国民财富的性质和原因研究(下)[M].郭大力,王亚南,译.北京:商务印书馆.(原书:SMITH A.[1776].An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations[M].London:W.Strahan and T.Cadell.)
- 万广华.2013.城镇化与不均等:分析方法和中国案例[J].经济研究,48(5):73-86.WAN G H.2013.Urbanization and inequality:Analytical methods and Chinese cases[J].Economic Research Journal,48(5):73-86.(in Chinese)
- 王德福.2017.弹性城市化与接力式进城---理解中国特色城市化模式及其社会机制的一个视角[J].社会科学,(3):66-74.WANG D F.2017.Flexible urbanization and ralayed down-town:A perspective of understanding Chinese characteristics urbanization mode and social mechanism[J].Journal of Social Sciences,(3):66-74.(in Chinese)
- 王镝,唐茂钢.2019.土地城市化如何影响生态环境质量?---基于动态最优化和空间自适应半参数模型的分析[J].经济研究,54(3):72-85.WANG D,TANG M G.2019.How does land urbanization affect ecological environment quality?Analysis based on dynamic optimization and spatially adaptive semi-parametric model[J].Economic Research Journal,54(3):72-85.(in Chinese)
- 王福君.2012.中国二三线城市房地产业现状与趋势[J].学术交流,214(1):100-103.WANG F J.2012.Current situation and trend of real estate industry in China's second and third tier cities[J].Academic Exchange,214(1):100-103.(in Chinese)
- 王检贵.2005.劳动与资本双重过剩下的经济发展[M].上海:上海三联出版社.WANG J G.2005.Labor and capital double over remaining economic development[M].Shanghai:Shanghai Sanlian Publishing House.(in Chinese)
- 杨小凯.2003.发展经济学:超边际与边际分析[M].北京:社会科学文献出版社.YANG X K.2003.Development Economics:Beyond marginal and marginal analysis[M].Beijing:Social Sciences Academic Press.(in Chinese)
- 姚震宇.2011.空间城市化机制和人口城市化目标---对中国当代城市化发展的一项研究[J].人口研究,(5):26-35.YAO Z Y.2011.Spatial urbanization mechanism and population urbanization target:A study on the development of urbanization in contemporary China[J].Population Research,35(5):26-35.(in Chinese)
- 袁富华.2012.长期增长过程的“结构性加速”与“结构性减速”:一种解释[J].经济研究,47(3):127-140.YUAN F H.2012.Structural accelerating and structural decelerating in the long run growth:An exposition[J].Economic Research Journal,47(3):127-140.(in Chinese)
- 中国人口与发展研究中心本文组.2012.中国人口城镇化战略研究[J].人口研究,36(3):3-13.This article group of China population and development research center.2012.China's urbanization strategy[J].Population Research,36(3):3-13.(in Chinese)
- ALONSO W.1964.Location and land use[M].Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
- BLACK D,HENDERSON J V.1999.A theory of urban growth[J].Journal of Political Economy,107(2):252-284.
- BOSKER M,BRAKMAN S,GARRETSEN H,et al.2012.Relaxing Hukou:Increased labor mobility and China's economic geography[J].Journal of Urban Economics,72(1):252-266.
- CHEN Q,SONG Z.2014.Accounting for China's urbanization[J].China Economic Review,30(1):485-494.
- DIXIT.1973.Short-run equilibrium and shadow prices in the dual economy[J].Oxford Economic Papers,23(3):384-400.
- DU H,MA Y,AN Y.2011.The impact of land policy on the relation between housing and land prices:Evidence from China[J].The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance,51(1):19-27.
- FU Q.2015.When fiscal recentralisation meets urban reforms:Prefectural land finance and its association with access to housing in urban China[J].Urban Studies,52(10):1791-1809.
- GLAESER E L.2008.Cities,agglomeration and spatial equilibrium[M].Oxford:Oxford University Press.
- HARRIS J R,TODARO M.1970.Migration,unemployment and development:A twosector analysis[J].American Economic Review,60(1):126-142.
- HARVEY D.1985.The urbanization of capital_studies in the history and theory of Capitalist Urbanization[M].Baltimore:The Johns Hopkins University Press.
- HENDERSON J V.1974.The sizes and types of cities[J].American Economic Review,64(1):640-656.
- HENDERSON J V.1977.Economic theory and the cities[M].New York:Academic Press.
- HENDERSON J V.1988.Urban development:Theory,fact,and illusion[M].Oxford:Oxford University press.
- JACOBS J.1970.The economy of cities[M].New York:Random House.
- JORGENSON D W.1961.The development of a dual economy[J].The Economic Journal,71(282):309-334.
- KAIN J F.1968.Housing segregation,negro employment,and metropolitan decentralization[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,82(2):175-197.
- KRUGMAN P.1991a.Increasing returns and economic geography[J].Journal of Political Economy,99(1):483-99.
- KRUGMAN P.1991b.Target zones and exchange rate dynamics[J].Quarterly Journal of Economics,102(3):669-682.
- LEWIS W A.1954.Economic development with unlimited supplies of labour[J].The Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies,22(2):139-191.
- LI B,LU Y.2009.Geographic concentration and vertical disintegration:Evidence from China[J].Journal of Urban Economics,65(3):294-304.
- LICHTENBERG E,DING C.2009.Local officials as land developers:Urban spatial expansion in China[J].Journal of Urban Economics,66(1):57-64.
- LI H,LI Z G.2013.Road investments and inventory reduction:Firm level evidence from China[J].Journal of Urban Economics,76(1):43-52.
- LI Z,LIANG Z.2016.Gender and job mobility among rural to urban temporary migrants in the Pearl River Delta in China[J].Urban Studies,53(16):3455-3471.
- LU J Y,TAO Z G.2009.Trends and determinants of China's industrial agglomeration[J].Journal of Urban Economics,65(1):167-180.
- MILLS E.1967.An aggregative model of resource allocation in a metropolitan area[J].American Economic Review,57(1):197-210.
- MUTH W R.1969.Cities and housing[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
- NURKSE R.1953.Problems of capital foundation in underdeveloped countries[M].New York:Oxford University Press.
- RAKSHIT M.1982.Labour surplus economy:A Neo-Keynesian approach[M].Delhi,India:Macmillan India Press.
- RANIS G,FEI J.1961.A theory of economic development[J].American Economic Review,51(4):76-106.
- TODARO M P.1969.A model of labor migration and urban unemployment in less developed countries[J].The American Economic Review,59(1):138-148.
- WU F,LOGAN J.2016.Do rural migrants“float”in urban China?Neighbouring and neighbourhood sentiment in Beijing[J].Urban Studies,53(14):2973-2990.
- YANG X,RICE R.1994.An equilibrium model endogenizing the emergence of a dual structure between the urban and rural sectors[J].Journal of Urban Economics,35(3):346-368.
- ZHENG S,SONG Z,SUN W.2020.Do affordable housing programs facilitate migrants'social integration in Chinese cities?[J].Cities,(96):102-449.
- (1)多数情况下,都市农业、屋顶农业会搞成一种景观工程或政绩工程,它产生不了多大的实际效应。
- (1)所谓移动就业模式,指的是利用互联网移动设备终端打造的灵活就业模式,特别指以移动设备作为就业的关键终端。
- (1)所谓“结构性减速”,袁富华(2012)将其解释为“生产率的减速是由于产业结构服务化这种系统性因素造成的现象”。
- (1)根据《中国统计年鉴2019》提供的数据计算所得,几个主要人口流入省市指北京、上海、广东、浙江、江苏、山东、福建等七个省市。参见:中华人民共和国国民经济和社会发展第十二个五年规划纲要[M].北京:人民出版社,2011:100,105.